UIL Speech Judges
If you have corrections, questions or comments regarding this information, please notify The UIL Speech and Debate department at speech@uiltexas.org or 512-471-5883.
Sasha Trukhnova
Current high school:
Manor New Tech
Currently coaching?: Yes
Conference:
Number of years coached:
Number of tournaments judged: 2
High school attended:
Lincoln High School
Graduated high school: 2022
Participated in high school: Yes
Participated in college: No
Judging qualifications:
I competed in Policy Debate all 4 years of high school, qualifying to Nationals and placing. I now coach Policy and LD + judge novice policy 1-2x a month.
Judging Philosophy
CX
Judging approach: Tabula Rasa
Policy priority: Communication skills and resolution of substantive issues are of equal importance
Evidence philosophy: Quality of evidence is more important than quantity of evidence
Paradigm: Hi! I am a high school English Lit teacher + Policy and LD coach in Manor, TX. I graduated from Emory University and did Policy Debate during all 4 years of high school in Oregon. I was primarily a K-debater but am comfortable with all argument types. I have judged minimal rounds on this year's topic. I love debate - creating a respectful and curious environment will go a long way! I am comfortable with all jargon and any speed but please email me the files you are reading sasha.trukhnova@gmail.com. That being said - unless you are a clear and experienced spreader, slow down on analytics and warrant analysis. If I don't flow it I can't evaluate it. Judge instruction on what my ballot should look like is super helpful. I will vote for the debater that wins framing - whether that be impact or other framing mechanisms. Convince me that your argument is most important, and that the ballot matters. A good debate round to me is one with thorough, in-depth arguments. One good card > five you won't warrant out or analyze. Reading one full card > cutting five after a few lines. Theory / Topicality: I am not the best judge for a theory debate. If this is what you are going for, clear weighing mechanisms and real-world implications are persuasive to me. I tend to err reject the arg > reject the team but I can be convinced otherwise. You need to articulate in round abuse or other convincing impacts. For other theory args, give me a specific link to the round and explain why that theory matters. Topicality can be fun if you can articulate the aff is actually not topical + it matters. Make sure you have a framework arg in topicality, or else I won't know how to weigh it. DA's and K's on the neg: topical and solid links to case are extremely persuasive. Links of omission or bad evidence are not convincing. I love creative debate. I will gladly judge any K’s, K-affs, or other ‘alternative’ framings, just make sure your argument is clear, concise, and strongly supported by evidence! I debated set-col, fem ks, queerness ks, Cap k, Neitzche, etc. That being said do NOT assume I am familiar with your lit base, spend time explaining your K + why it matters. K debates are meant to be critical, not a contest of who can use the most big words. Neg K's: Weigh the alt vs. the plan, have strong links, spend time on impact framing. This should go without saying but be respectful to everyone in the round. Don't speak over your partner or attempt to agitate the other team, it won't reflect well in your speaks. Please disclose! Disclosure is good! Have fun! It will be more enjoyable for everyone!
LD
Approach: Communication skills and resolution of substantive issues are of equal importance
Philosophy:
Hi! I am a high school English Lit teacher + Policy and LD coach in Manor, TX. I graduated from Emory University and did Policy Debate during all 4 years of high school in Oregon. I was primarily a K-debater but am comfortable with all argument types. I have judged minimal rounds on this year's topic. I love debate - creating a respectful and curious environment will go a long way! I am comfortable with all jargon and any speed but please email me the files you are reading sasha.trukhnova@gmail.com. That being said - unless you are a clear and experienced spreader, slow down on analytics and warrant analysis. If I don't flow it I can't evaluate it. Judge instruction on what my ballot should look like is super helpful. I will vote for the debater that wins framing - whether that be impact or other framing mechanisms. Convince me that your argument is most important, and that the ballot matters. A good debate round to me is one with thorough, in-depth arguments. One good card > five you won't warrant out or analyze. Reading one full card > cutting five after a few lines. Theory / Topicality: I am not the best judge for a theory debate. If this is what you are going for, clear weighing mechanisms and real-world implications are persuasive to me. I tend to err reject the arg > reject the team but I can be convinced otherwise. You need to articulate in round abuse or other convincing impacts. For other theory args, give me a specific link to the round and explain why that theory matters. Topicality can be fun if you can articulate the aff is actually not topical + it matters. Make sure you have a framework arg in topicality, or else I won't know how to weigh it. DA's and K's on the neg: topical and solid links to case are extremely persuasive. Links of omission or bad evidence are not convincing. I love creative debate. I will gladly judge any K’s, K-affs, or other ‘alternative’ framings, just make sure your argument is clear, concise, and strongly supported by evidence! I debated set-col, fem ks, queerness ks, Cap k, Neitzche, etc. That being said do NOT assume I am familiar with your lit base, spend time explaining your K + why it matters. K debates are meant to be critical, not a contest of who can use the most big words. Neg K's: Weigh the alt vs. the plan, have strong links, spend time on impact framing. This should go without saying but be respectful to everyone in the round. Don't speak over your partner or attempt to agitate the other team, it won't reflect well in your speaks. Please disclose! Disclosure is good! Have fun! It will be more enjoyable for everyone!
Contact Information
email: sasha.trukhnova@manorisd.net
cell:
office:
Availability Information
Meet types:
Invitational
District
Regional
CX State
Qualified for:
CX
LD
Travel
Region of residence:
1
I will travel to: 1


